When it rains, it pours! In last Tuesday's hard-blowing storm, we got around 2.25" of rain in about a 24 hour period. Coupled with strong winds, the storm left quite the mess in its wake. A regular question I've been fielding over the last couple of days is: did you guys lose any trees? And the truth is, yes we did. But if you want my opinion, I'm not too broken up about it. And here are the reasons why:
Don't get me wrong. I like trees. I'm a nature-lover in general. Trees are beautiful, majestic and serve many useful purposes on many golf courses, like providing shade and increasing the difficulty of the layout, which are the main two reasons trees were planted here at Empire Ranch. And yet while these reasons remain valid and important, there are just as many (if not more) important reasons to keep trees away from a golf course that never had them in the first place. Or at the very least, plant trees only in specific location that will not effect maintenance and health of the turf. After all, we play golf on grass, not trees, right?
Trees pose a number of challanges for a superintendent and the maintenance crew, many of which may go largely unnoticed by golfers. Many trees drop leaves, twigs and other debris. This all takes time and manpower to clean up. Manpower that could be spent elsewhere improving more important aspects of the golf course. Trees create immense amounts of shade; good for the hot, sweating golfer on a 100+ degree day, bad for growing healthy turfgrass. Almost all grass types (specifically those suitable for surfaces on which to play golf) need full sun all day in order to take part in enough photosynthesis to stay happy and healthy while being trampled and driven on all day long. Trees present a wide variety of issues with their root systems. All trees roots suck up moisture to keep the tree alive. This directly competes with the moisture needed by the turfgrass. Deep rooting tress can also clog up drainlines installed throughout the course to keep playing conditions fast and firm and render the drain useless, causing wet boggy areas even where a drain is known to have been installed. Trees that have many roots near the surface can heave up cart paths and invade into key playing areas like tees, greens and bunkers. These surface roots can also cause great damage to the mowers that have to try and mow around or over them while cutting grass.
So I'm not a tree-hater, but I guess when it comes to my job, I'm not a full-on tree hugger either. I love playing the mountain courses that wind through the forest. I love playing older, local country clubs with huge majestic oaks. But I think it deserves to be recognized that trees and, more importantly, how and where they are planted can largely impact both the game of golf and those of us who do our best to maintain pristine grounds on which to play on. So when we have big storms like we just had, my rule is: survival of the fittest. We'll always do our best to preserve specimen trees (think the oaks on #15 and #17) and key trees strategic to the design of the hole, but if one tree goes down in a group or line due to it being unhealthy or poorly rooted, I don't think too many golfers will notice it, or miss it. And as a superintendent, I won't either.
Future posts this winter will expand on the ongoing issues created by the trees that have already been planted here at Empire Ranch. Many chores on our winter list of "to-do's" have to do with correcting these problem areas. But if you're on the course and want to check it out for yourself, remember these key areas: the roots invading near the back of #4 green, the roots invading the back bunker on #8, and the roots heaving up the cart path on #17.